Danielle Laidley has delivered her comprehensive player ratings for every West Coast Eagle and Fremantle Docker following the round nine AFL matches. The analysis provides an in-depth look at individual performances, highlighting standout players and those who need improvement.
West Coast Eagles Ratings
The Eagles faced a tough contest, with several players stepping up despite the overall team result. Tim Kelly was among the best, earning a high rating for his midfield dominance and two goals. Oscar Allen continued his strong form in the forward line, while Tom Barrass was solid in defense. However, some players struggled to make an impact, with Jack Darling and Jamie Cripps rated lower due to quiet games.
Key Performers
- Tim Kelly: 8/10 – 25 disposals, 5 clearances, 2 goals
- Oscar Allen: 7.5/10 – 3 goals, 10 marks
- Tom Barrass: 7/10 – 12 intercepts, 8 marks
Underperformers
- Jack Darling: 4/10 – 8 disposals, 1 mark
- Jamie Cripps: 5/10 – 12 disposals, no score
Fremantle Dockers Ratings
The Dockers had a mixed outing, with some players shining brightly. Andrew Brayshaw was exceptional, racking up 30 disposals and a goal. Caleb Serong also impressed in the midfield, while Luke Ryan was reliable in defense. On the downside, Michael Walters had a quiet game, and Nathan O'Driscoll struggled to find the ball.
Key Performers
- Andrew Brayshaw: 8.5/10 – 30 disposals, 6 tackles, 1 goal
- Caleb Serong: 8/10 – 28 disposals, 4 clearances
- Luke Ryan: 7.5/10 – 15 marks, 9 rebound 50s
Underperformers
- Michael Walters: 4.5/10 – 10 disposals, 1 tackle
- Nathan O'Driscoll: 5/10 – 8 disposals, 2 tackles
The ratings reflect the challenges both teams face as they aim to climb the ladder. With the season progressing, consistency will be key for the Eagles and Dockers to turn their fortunes around.
