Questions are once again being directed at Melbourne's medical team after footage emerged of Jai Culley having his knee assessed before he ultimately suffered a suspected anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. The 23-year-old, formerly of West Coast, initially hurt his left leg in the first quarter and then went down for good late in the second quarter against Richmond on Friday night at the MCG.
Vision Raises Concerns
7NEWS sports reporter Xander McGuire presented footage showing Culley's knee appearing to buckle under him during the first term. “At quarter time, he goes over to a physio, points out the discomfort, and then completes a range of tests, as we can see (in this vision),” McGuire said. “He’s deemed fit to continue. He goes out in the second quarter, the knee buckles under him again, and ultimately he’s ruled out for the rest of the game. And that’s a typical ACL mechanism.”
Culley was seen on the bench after going down with the injury. McGuire asked, “He’s quite emotional (at the end of the game) ... From your perspective, how did that play out, and should there have been more checks and balances to make sure he didn’t go back out in the second quarter?”
Expert Opinions Divided
AFL legend Matthew Richardson defended the medical team, stating, “I think the physio would have checked everything out and would have assumed that everything was fine.” However, Channel 7 star Abbey Holmes countered, “That vision’s pretty damning, though.” Richardson replied, “I wouldn’t want to throw the physio under the bus there. I’m sure he’s done all the tests.”
Collingwood premiership hero Dale Thomas emphasised trust in the medical staff, saying, “If Jai was worried about it to the extent of, ‘hey, this is what I felt’ ... didn’t even go out with any taping or strapping around it. He must have been confident with it. Just unfortunate circumstances, I feel.”
McGuire noted that it was plausible a structural test showed the ACL was intact despite a slight tear. “And at that stage, you can only assume that there’s a slight discomfort, and you wouldn’t know at the time, but ... there could have been nothing as well,” he said. “The fact that there is almost a mechanism that might put the ACL at risk in the first quarter, and then he goes in to the second is one that will be talked about in the next 24 hours, at least.”
Culley’s Emotional Reaction
Culley was seen wiping away tears at half-time as teammates rallied around him. He signed with Melbourne’s VFL affiliate Casey for 2025 before earning an AFL list spot as a pre-season signing. After missing time last year with a stress fracture in his foot, he impressed new coach Steven King to be selected in every game so far in 2026 and secured a contract extension until the end of 2028. Now, he appears resigned to another ACL injury. “That’s just shattering for him,” Richardson said. “He’s obviously been to a club, he’s come to another club, he’s had a previous knee, he’s had to work so hard to get to this position. So you can see why he’d be shattered.”
Melbourne’s Medical History Under Scrutiny
This incident again puts Melbourne’s medical team under the microscope. Only this week, after 681 days, the AFL completed its investigation into the failings when former star Christian Petracca was hospitalised with a lacerated spleen. Petracca suffered a severe knock during the 2024 King’s Birthday clash with Collingwood and missed the rest of the season. Despite the injury, he was sent back onto the field, and Melbourne later learned the seriousness, leading to several days in intensive care. Petracca became disgruntled with the club’s handling, requested a trade at the end of 2024 and again in 2025, when he moved to Gold Coast.
The investigation resulted in four findings to be introduced into AFL protocol for serious injuries: changes to pre-match briefings with a comprehensive plan for match-day staff and medical teams, detailing local emergency hospitals and communication channels; aligning processes across all states and venues; mandatory bi-annual emergency care courses for club doctors, physios, and head trainers; and tightening audit processes with automatic review of all emergency match-day incidents, in line with public health systems.
Melbourne has also faced questions about the lack of clarity around Harrison Petty’s recent injury. A week after Petty became unsteady on his feet during a game, he remains absent from the club’s injury list, with the AFL listing him as “TBC”. Melbourne football performance boss Alan Richardson said on Tuesday, “We’re currently gathering further information and once it comes to hand, we will provide an update.”
Stream free on 7plus.
