The cost to Newcastle ratepayers for investigating alleged misconduct by city officials has surged dramatically, with new data revealing a sharp increase in both complaints and expenses.
Complaints Double as Costs Skyrocket
City of Newcastle spent $56,696 more dealing with code of conduct complaints in the 2024-2025 period compared to two years prior. The total cost to ratepayers reached $62,689, which includes staff time and resources.
During the reporting period from September 1, 2024, to August 31, 2025, the council received a total of nine formal complaints. This marks a significant jump from the four complaints recorded in the 2022-2023 financial year.
Breakdown of Complaints and Outcomes
The nine complaints targeted councillors or the chief executive, Jeremy Bath. Their origins were varied:
- Two from members of the public
- Four from fellow councillors
- Two from Mr Bath himself
- One from a council staff member
Importantly, none of the nine complaints have resulted in a formal finding of wrongdoing to date. However, the process remains incomplete, with four complaints yet to be finalised.
The council referred eight of the complaints to an independent conduct reviewer for assessment. Of these:
- Three were finalised at the preliminary assessment stage.
- One was sent back to the chief executive or lord mayor for resolution.
- Four progressed to a full investigation.
The outcomes for those investigated saw no action taken on two complaints, while one was resolved using alternative strategies. The preliminary assessment phase alone cost $39,583.
Understanding the Code of Conduct Process
A code of conduct complaint must allege behaviour by a council official that, if proven, would breach the standards set out in the council's code. This document outlines minimum behaviour requirements for councillors, staff, and committee members.
It is crucial to note that these complaints do not cover general service issues, council policy decisions, or procedural matters. Complaints must typically be lodged within three months of the alleged conduct occurring, or within three months of the complainant becoming aware of it.
Investigations are conducted confidentially and without undue delay. While no complaints were referred to bodies like the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) or NSW Police during this period, one was forwarded to the Office of Local Government.
The complaint data is scheduled for presentation to Newcastle councillors at their upcoming Tuesday meeting, prompting further scrutiny of the processes and costs involved in upholding conduct standards within the local government.
