NSW Health Minister Evades Scrutiny Over Hospital's Dire Maintenance Failures
NSW Health Minister Ryan Park has declined to respond to pressing inquiries regarding the deteriorating conditions at Calvary Mater Hospital in Waratah. This follows the closure of two hospital wards within a fortnight due to alarming incidents involving maggots falling from ceiling vents and a widespread air conditioning mould infestation. The situation has intensified demands to terminate the private operation of the facility.
Growing Pressure to End Private Hospital Management
Greens politician Amanda Cohn has publicly questioned the Minns Labor government's inaction, contrasting it with their previous decision to reclaim the Northern Beaches Hospital from a public-private partnership (PPP). "Where is this decisive action for the patients and families who rely on the Mater in Newcastle?" Dr Cohn stated. She emphasised that if maggots descending from ceilings do not warrant contract termination, it raises serious concerns about the thresholds for intervention in healthcare standards.
Dr Cohn further argued that the for-profit model has proven detrimental, asserting that private providers should not be involved in public health care delivery. Her comments highlight a broader debate over the efficacy and safety of PPPs in the health sector.
Private Operator's Defence Amidst Systemic Failures
Honeywell, the private company responsible for infrastructure and maintenance as part of the Novacare consortium, defended its actions. A spokesperson claimed the company is "going above and beyond its contractual obligations" to address leaks, mitigate mould risks, and safeguard patient and staff welfare. Regarding the maggot incident, Honeywell reported engaging a pest control specialist for remediation, with findings suggesting the maggots originated externally and were unrelated to the mould problem.
However, Calvary Health Care, which manages the hospital, has criticised the PPP for "ongoing systemic failures," with numerous dangerous maintenance issues remaining unresolved. The Newcastle Herald revealed that Calvary's CEO has accused the government of failing to compel Novacare to fix these problems despite repeated warnings.
Government Response and Contractual Reviews
When confronted with these allegations, Minister Park provided a brief, ten-word response: "My priority is getting this resolved as quickly as possible." This has sparked criticism over transparency and accountability in handling the crisis.
NSW Health has denied neglecting the hospital's needs or failing to hold Novacare accountable. A spokesperson indicated that following the maggot incident, the government is "urgently reviewing the contractual consequences." Additionally, the Hunter New England Health District issued a breach notice to Novacare over the mould issues, one of the strongest measures under the PPP contract, to ensure remediation meets required standards.
Novacare has submitted a draft remediation plan, with work already commenced. The company estimates that replacing mechanical systems and ductwork will continue over several months. Wallsend MP Sonia Hornery echoed the Minister's sentiment, expressing frustration and ongoing discussions with Park to expedite a resolution.
The ongoing crisis at Calvary Mater Hospital underscores significant challenges in public-private healthcare partnerships, with patient safety at the forefront of community and political concerns.
