An aged care provider is weighing legal action after its contentious high-rise development in the eastern suburbs was denied planning approval last week. The ACH Group’s proposed retirement living complex in Rose Park was refused consent by the State Commission Assessment Panel (SCAP), drawing a sharp response from the provider.
Company expresses disappointment
ACH Group chief executive Charlie Gilchrist described the decision as “very disappointing,” noting that the project aimed to address growing demand for aged care accommodation in the area. “We have spent significant time and resources developing a proposal that we believe meets the needs of older South Australians,” Gilchrist said. “The refusal is a setback for those seeking modern retirement options close to existing community facilities.”
Community opposition cited
The proposed high-rise had drawn strong opposition from local residents and the Burnside Council, who argued the building’s height and scale were inappropriate for the low-density neighbourhood. SCAP’s refusal cited non-compliance with planning rules, including excessive building height and inadequate setbacks. The panel also noted that the development would have an adverse impact on the character of the heritage area.
Legal options explored
ACH Group is now reviewing its options, including a potential appeal to the Environment, Resources and Development Court. “We are considering all avenues to ensure that the needs of older people are not ignored,” Gilchrist added. The provider emphasised that the facility would have included 120 independent living units, as well as common areas and support services.
Future of aged care in the area
The refusal has reignited debate about how to accommodate an ageing population in established suburbs. Local advocates argue that higher-density aged care facilities are necessary to allow seniors to remain in their communities. However, residents maintain that development must respect existing neighbourhood character. The outcome of any legal challenge could set a precedent for similar projects across metropolitan Adelaide.
