Knights Coach Faces Tough Halves Decision After Dragons Trial
Newcastle Knights coach Justin Holbrook faces a significant selection headache as he determines who will partner marquee signing Dylan Brown in the halves for the upcoming NRL season. The decision comes after the Knights' 28-18 trial loss to the St George Illawarra Dragons at Kogarah Oval on Saturday night.
Impressive Performances Create Selection Conundrum
Both Fletcher Sharpe and Sandon Smith delivered compelling performances in Newcastle's first pre-season hit-out, making Holbrook's decision increasingly difficult. Smith started at halfback while Sharpe lined up at five-eighth, with each player demonstrating their value throughout the contest.
Sandon Smith, the 23-year-old recruit from the Sydney Roosters, showed excellent game management and kicking skills. His highlight moment came late in the first half when he delivered a pinpoint cut-out pass to set up winger James Schiller for a try. Smith's steady hand and organisational skills impressed observers throughout his time on the field.
Fletcher Sharpe, playing his first match since suffering a lacerated kidney and ruptured spleen last June, reminded everyone of his attacking prowess. The 21-year-old produced several elusive runs and contributed to Newcastle's attacking opportunities, showing no signs of being hampered by his previous serious injury.
Coach's Perspective on the Selection Battle
Speaking after the match, Holbrook acknowledged the quality of both players while remaining non-committal about his final decision. "I liked them. I thought they both complement each other really well," Holbrook said. "Obviously Dylan Brown will play next week, so only one of them will start there. I'll work that out in the next couple of days."
The coach emphasised that he was pleased with both options, stating: "I'm happy whichever way we go. I think they're both very, very good players. I was happy with how they played. I thought we created some really good opportunities when they were in the halves together."
Expert Commentary Adds to the Debate
Former NRL star Kieran Foran, providing commentary during the match, was particularly impressed with Sharpe's performance. "I could not leave this guy out of the team," Foran said. "If I'm Justin, it's a healthy headache to have, but he's going to have to find somewhere for him in the 13. I think you want him out there for the full 80. He's that good."
Foran's comments highlight the broader question of how Holbrook might utilise both players, suggesting Sharpe's talent demands inclusion in the starting side regardless of position.
Trial Context and Missing Players
The trial match itself was a scrappy affair, with both teams missing significant numbers of their top-line players. Newcastle were without several key figures including:
- Captain Kalyn Ponga (foot injury)
- Dane Gagai (hamstring)
- Dom Young
- Dylan Lucas
- Phoenix Crossland
- Bradman Best
Additionally, emerging talents Cody Hopwood and Jermaine McEwen were late withdrawals due to minor injuries. Holbrook confirmed that most players would be available for the Knights' second trial against Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs next week, with only Ponga and Gagai likely to miss out.
Positive Signs Despite Defeat
Despite the loss, Holbrook found several encouraging aspects in his team's performance. "There was some really good signs," he noted. "I thought we created enough opportunities in attack, and we defended really well. We conceded, I think two from long-range intercepts, and three off kick tries, so we really only conceded one off a poor defensive effort."
The coach also praised the efforts of several players, including Fletcher Hunt who he described as "great" and "dangerous everywhere" he was positioned on the field.
Looking Ahead to Bulldogs Clash
Newcastle's attention now turns to their second pre-season trial against the Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs at McDonald Jones Stadium next Saturday. This match will provide Holbrook with another opportunity to assess his options before making a final decision on his halves combination.
The coach indicated he would use this week to review footage and consider his options carefully. "I'll have a look at the video," Holbrook said regarding the halves decision. "I'll work that out in the next couple of days."
With Dylan Brown expected to return for the Bulldogs trial, the competition between Sharpe and Smith for the remaining halves spot intensifies. Both players have presented strong cases for selection, leaving Holbrook with what he described as a "healthy headache" as he prepares his side for their season opener against North Queensland in Las Vegas on March 1.
