Newcastle Knights head coach Justin Holbrook has given his qualified support to a major NRL proposal, suggesting a move to a six-man interchange bench would offer a significant tactical advantage for clubs.
NRL's Proposed Rule Changes for 2026 Season
The game's governing body is currently considering several key alterations ahead of the 2026 premiership campaign. The most discussed changes include allowing teams to select their four interchange players from an extended bench of six, up from the current four. Other proposals involve increasing match-day squads from 17 to 19 players and giving the team that has just conceded a try the option to either kick off or receive the ball to restart play.
Holbrook acknowledged the game is in a strong position but stated evolution is necessary. "I think all the rules that got put forward, everyone agrees our game is in a great spot, but we've got to keep evolving," Holbrook said. He admitted he isn't spending excessive time analysing the potential changes, leaving the final decisions to the administrators.
However, he highlighted a practical benefit of a larger bench. "We saw some games last year where you can lose an outside back early and not have one on the bench, and it can have a huge influence on the game," Holbrook explained, noting teams are often forced to play forwards out of position in the backs.
How a Bigger Bench Impacts Knights' Selection Puzzle
The proposed six-man bench could arrive at an ideal time for Holbrook, who faces a welcome selection headache in his star-studded backline and spine. The coach is weighing up a likely halves partnership of Dylan Brown and either Sandon Smith or Fletcher Sharpe. This decision could also affect the hooker position, where Smith might play if Phoenix Crossland moves to lock forward.
Sharpe, who has scored an impressive 22 tries in just 26 NRL games, has proven his versatility over the past two seasons, covering fullback, wing, and the halves. However, with Kalyn Ponga at fullback and Greg Marzhew and Dom Young on the wings, and the established centre pairing of Bradman Best and Dane Gagai, a starting spot is not guaranteed for the Cessnock junior.
An expanded bench would allow Holbrook to carry a specialist backline player or an extra playmaker without sacrificing forward depth. "Definitely," Holbrook said when asked if a bigger bench allows for more specialist roles. "Tactics become a bigger part in that. You might save your last reserve up for whatever is needed. If you are in front, you put a defensive player on, and if you need points, you put an attacking player on."
While this makes Sharpe a logical candidate for a super-sub role, Holbrook's preference is clear. "I'd like him in the starting side," the coach asserted. "I think wherever 'Fletch' plays he is going to have a big influence on a game. He is an electrifying player."
Controversial Kick-Off Change and Other Proposals
Among the suggested rule tweaks, the option to choose to receive the ball after conceding a try has sparked the most debate among fans and clubs alike. This would break a tradition dating back to 1908. Holbrook appeared less convinced by this particular change.
"I'm not sure if that's going to be put in," he commented. "At the moment, it's just a recommendation. Until it gets confirmed, I'm not really going to look into it too much." He added that game situation would dictate the choice if it were introduced.
Other proposed adjustments include:
- Awarding a defending team a six-tackle set (instead of seven) from the 20-metre line if an attacker drops the ball over the try-line.
- Granting set restarts, rather than full penalties, for infringements outside an attacking team's 20-metre zone. Full penalties would only apply inside the 20-metre area, a reduction from last season's 40-metre threshold.
Reports indicate these potential changes have caused concern for a majority of the NRL's 17 clubs, who have urged the league not to rush implementation and to trial them in reserve grade first.
Ultimately, Holbrook maintains a pragmatic outlook. "I'm happy either way. If it's six, great. If it's four, all the clubs are used to that and we will deal with the versatility needed," he said. "Whatever the rules are, I'll be happy with and get on with it."
