West Coast Eagles Player Ratings: Heartbreaking Loss to Richmond
Eagles Player Ratings: Heartbreaking Loss to Richmond

West Coast were on the wrong end of a heartbreaking finish in front of their 2006 premiership heroes, going down by 11 points to Richmond. Here is our three-word analysis of every Eagle.

Player Analysis

Harley Reid

Strong start, faded – Reid showed glimpses of brilliance early but couldn't sustain his impact throughout the match.

Jake Waterman

Found goal-kicking radar – Waterman rediscovered his accuracy in front of goal, providing a reliable target up forward.

Wide Pickt banner — collaborative shopping lists app for Telegram, phone mockup with grocery list

Liam Baker

Stay at half-back! – Baker was influential when stationed in the backline, suggesting that is his best position.

Elliot Yeo

Wound clock back – Yeo turned back the clock with a vintage performance, reminiscent of his best days.

Jobe Shanahan

Hands so good – Shanahan displayed clean hands in contested situations, proving a reliable link-up player.

Willem Duursma

More tantalising moments – Duursma continued to show flashes of his potential, leaving fans wanting more.

Camera Icon: Willem Duursma was impressive again. Credit: Daniel Carson/AFL Photos/AFL Photos via Getty Images

Josh Lindsay

Rushed at times – Lindsay's decision-making was occasionally hurried, leading to turnovers.

Reuben Ginbey

Enthralling Lynch battle – Ginbey engaged in a compelling duel with Tom Lynch, holding his own for the most part.

Liam Duggan

Ball use better – Duggan improved his disposal efficiency, making better use of the ball when in possession.

Milan Murdock

An 'almost' game – Murdock was close to having a breakout performance but just fell short.

Tom McCarthy

Was brave again – McCarthy showed courage once more, putting his body on the line for the team.

Camera Icon: Tom McCarthy was tough. Credit: Janelle St Pierre/AFL Photos/via Getty Images

Bailey Williams

Hit-outs not impactful – Williams struggled to make his ruck work count, with his hit-outs not translating to clearances.

Tim Kelly

Quietly strong season – Kelly continued his consistent season, influencing the game without fanfare.

Cooper Duff-Tytler

May need rest – The youngster looked fatigued and could benefit from a spell.

Brady Hough

Down on form – Hough was below his usual standard, struggling to have an impact.

Elijah Hewett

Only rarely sighted – Hewett was largely anonymous, unable to get into the game.

Ryan Maric

Solid on wing – Maric performed reliably on the wing, providing good run and carry.

Tylar Young

Rocks and diamonds – Young mixed good moments with errors, showing inconsistency.

Matt Owies

Best Eagles game? – Owies may have played his finest game for West Coast, making a strong contribution.

Malakai Champion

Brilliant first goal! – Champion kicked a spectacular first AFL goal, a highlight of the match.

Camera Icon: Malakai Champion celebrates his first AFL goal. Credit: Paul Kane/Getty Images

Tom Cole

Battled sore knee – Cole played through a knee injury, showing resilience.

Hamish Davis

Some speedy bursts – Davis provided pace at times, breaking lines with his speed.

Harry Schoenberg

Struggled for impact – Schoenberg found it difficult to influence the contest.

Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox. Sign up for our emails.

Pickt after-article banner — collaborative shopping lists app with family illustration