The cricket world is in uproar after a controversial no-catch decision cost the Perth Scorchers dearly in their Big Bash League clash against the Melbourne Renegades on Wednesday night. Teenager Ollie Peake was given a second life after a catch by Ashton Turner was overturned by the TV umpire, and Peake went on to hit the winning runs from the final ball.
Turner appeared to take a clean catch in the in-field, dismissing Peake on 15 when the Renegades needed 37 off 21 balls. However, as Peake walked off, he was called back after a review. TV umpire Stephen Dionysius ruled that Turner was not in control of his body as he landed, and the ball touched the ground.
The decision left commentators and fans stunned. Brendon Julian said, “Wow, not out. Let off.” Shane Watson added, “Amazing how he had full control over the ball in his hand – but because he was off balance … it’s not out.” Brad Haddin suggested Turner fell that way to protect his injured shoulder but believed the right call was made.
According to Law 33.3 of the MCC Laws of Cricket, a catch is complete only when the fielder has full control over both the ball and their body movement. Any contact with the ground, even if the ball is secure, nullifies the catch if the fielder is not in full control of their momentum. The incident drew comparisons to Mitchell Starc’s overturned catch in the 2023 Ashes.
Fans expressed fury on social media, with one calling the rule “embarrassing” and another saying, “Common sense gone. Clearly under control before the ground.” The decision proved crucial as Peake hit a six off the last ball to lead the Renegades to a four-wicket win.
