Greens Demand Ban as Minister Orders Councils to Dismantle Anti-Homeless Noise Devices
Local Government Minister Hannah Beazley has issued a stern warning to councils across the state, demanding the immediate removal of any hostile noise devices designed to target rough sleepers. This directive comes just days after the City of Perth and the Public Transport Authority faced intense scrutiny over a high-pitched tone installed at the Lord Street underpass near McIver Station in East Perth.
The controversial speaker, which was intended to deter homeless individuals from loitering, was switched off on Tuesday. However, investigations have revealed similar devices operating at other locations, including a privately-owned Wilson carpark in the Central Business District.
Minister's Memo Calls for Immediate Action
In a memo obtained by The West Australian and sent to all local governments on Thursday, Minister Beazley expressed strong disapproval of the noise deterrents. She stated unequivocally that the installation of such devices should never have occurred, describing them as hostile measures that are an inappropriate way to treat people.
"It is a hostile measure and is not how people should be treated," Beazley wrote. "If there are similar devices operating in your municipality, it is requested that they are immediately switched off and dismantled."
Greens Push for Enforceable Ban
Greens MP Tim Clifford has escalated the issue, calling for tougher action beyond the minister's request. Clifford claims he discovered three additional noise devices in the CBD within just 45 minutes on Wednesday, highlighting the widespread nature of the problem.
"It's really troubling that nothing has been done about them even after that story had broken," Clifford said. "There needs to be a ban that's enforceable so these devices won't be deployed across the State."
While welcoming the acknowledgment that these devices are horrendous, Clifford emphasized that a mere request from the minister is insufficient. He argues that only a formal, legally enforceable ban can prevent future use of such deterrents.
Council Defends Use Amid Controversy
The City of Perth has defended its initial request for the noise device, citing reports of anti-social and criminal behavior in the area, including issues involving cyclists. In response to the backlash, the Public Transport Authority stated on Tuesday that it would collaborate with the City of Perth to determine a more suitable way forward.
This incident is not the first time noise deterrents have sparked public outrage. In 2023, the City of Bunbury faced severe criticism for playing The Wiggles' song Hot Potato on loop to discourage people from sleeping around a public amphitheatre. The backlash was so significant that The Wiggles themselves intervened, banning the city from using their music for such purposes.
Broader Implications for Homeless Policy
The controversy underscores ongoing tensions between public safety concerns and the humane treatment of vulnerable populations. As councils grapple with balancing these issues, the minister's directive and the Greens' demands highlight a growing push for more compassionate approaches to homelessness.
With devices still being discovered in various locations, the effectiveness of the minister's request remains to be seen. Advocates argue that without legislative backing, similar hostile measures could resurface, perpetuating a cycle of exclusion and discomfort for those sleeping rough.
