An inquest into the death of Sheffield United women's footballer Maddy Cusack has concluded that the club failed in its duty of care towards her, with harassment and bullying by then-manager Jonathan Morgan contributing to her deteriorating mental health. The 27-year-old died by suicide in September 2023, and the inquest, held at Derby Coroner's Court, heard that she had been subjected to inappropriate comments and behaviour from Morgan.
Findings of the Inquest
Senior coroner Dr Robert Hunter recorded a narrative conclusion, stating that Cusack took her own life while suffering from anxiety and depression, to which Morgan's conduct was a significant contributing factor. The inquest heard that Morgan made inappropriate remarks about Cusack's appearance, including commenting on her weight, and engaged in behaviour that was controlling and manipulative. He also sent her a series of messages that were described as harassing.
The inquest also found that Sheffield United failed to provide adequate support or investigate Cusack's complaints about Morgan's behaviour. The club's human resources department did not take appropriate action, and Cusack felt isolated and unsupported.
Club's Response
Sheffield United issued a statement expressing regret over the findings and apologising for the failures identified. The club said it had implemented changes to its safeguarding and welfare policies since Cusack's death, including appointing a dedicated welfare officer and providing mental health training for staff. However, the club stopped short of accepting full responsibility, stating that it could not have foreseen the tragic outcome.
Family's Reaction
Cusack's family welcomed the inquest findings but said they were devastated by the loss of their daughter and sister. In a statement, they said: "Maddy was a vibrant, talented young woman who loved football. The fact that she felt she had no other option but to take her own life is a tragedy that could have been prevented. We hope that the lessons learned from this inquest will ensure that no other family has to go through what we have."
Wider Implications for Women's Football
The case has raised broader concerns about the treatment of female players in professional football. Campaigners have called for stronger safeguarding measures and independent oversight of clubs' duty of care. The Football Association (FA) said it was reviewing its policies in light of the inquest and urged anyone experiencing abuse in football to come forward.
The inquest heard that Morgan, who was sacked by Sheffield United in November 2023, had a history of similar behaviour. He was previously employed by Leicester City, where he faced allegations of misconduct, though no formal action was taken. Morgan did not attend the inquest and has not commented publicly on the findings.
Conclusion
The inquest into Maddy Cusack's death has exposed serious failings in Sheffield United's duty of care and highlighted the need for systemic change in women's football. Cusack's family and advocates continue to call for justice and improved protections for players.
