Collingwood's Brayden Maynard has become one of the most talked-about players in the AFL, not just for his on-field performances but for the polarising reactions he elicits from fans and pundits alike. Yet, beneath the controversy lies a player whose toughness, skill, and tactical intelligence make him a dream asset for any coach—even those on the opposing side.
Maynard's Unique Brand of Football
Maynard, a 28-year-old defender, has built a reputation as a hard-nosed, no-nonsense player who thrives in the physical contests that define Australian rules football. His ability to read the play, intercept marks, and launch attacking moves from the backline has made him a cornerstone of Collingwood's defensive structure. In the 2025 season, he averaged 18.7 disposals and 5.2 intercepts per game, according to AFL statistics, underscoring his dual role as a stopper and a playmaker.
But it is his physicality that draws the most attention. Maynard's tackles are fierce, his bumping technique is legal but borderline, and his willingness to put his body on the line has earned him both admirers and critics. Opposition supporters often boo him, but coaches see something else: a player who dictates the tempo and unsettles opponents.
Opposition Coaches' Admiration
“Every coach wants a player like Brayden Maynard on their team,” said a former AFL coach who spoke on condition of anonymity. “He’s the type of player you hate to play against but love to have. He sets the tone, he’s courageous, and he makes the opposition think twice. That’s invaluable.”
This sentiment is echoed by current coaches, who privately acknowledge Maynard's impact. His ability to shut down key forwards while also providing rebound drive is a rare combination. In Collingwood's 2024 preliminary final win, Maynard held his direct opponent to just one goal while gathering 24 disposals and eight marks, a performance that drew praise from his own coach, Craig McRae.
Controversy and Resilience
Maynard's career has not been without incident. His bump on Melbourne's Angus Brayshaw in the 2023 qualifying final sparked a heated debate about the future of physical contact in the AFL. The incident led to a suspension and a league-wide review of bumping rules. Yet, Maynard has shown resilience, adapting his game without losing his edge. He has reduced the number of high-impact bumps while maintaining his physical presence, a testament to his professionalism.
“He’s learned from that experience and come back a better player,” said Collingwood teammate Jack Crisp. “He knows where the line is now, but he hasn’t lost that competitive fire. That’s what makes him special.”
The Statistical Picture
Maynard's numbers back up the hype. In 2025, he ranked in the top 10% of defenders for pressure acts, intercepts, and spoils, according to Champion Data. His one-on-one win rate of 68% placed him among the league's elite. These stats paint a picture of a player who not only defends but also initiates attack, often by foot with his penetrating left-foot kick.
His leadership off the field is equally important. Maynard is a vocal presence in the Collingwood locker room, often mentoring younger defenders like Isaac Quaynor and John Noble. His experience in big games—he has played in three grand finals, winning one—adds a layer of composure to the Magpies' backline.
Why Coaches Want Him
Opposition coaches, while publicly respectful, privately express a mix of frustration and admiration. “He’s a nightmare to plan against,” one assistant coach admitted. “You know he’s going to be physical, but he’s also smart. He baits forwards into making mistakes, and he’s never out of position. If you try to exploit his aggression, he just adapts.”
Maynard's versatility is another asset. He can play on small, medium, and even tall forwards, making him a matchup nightmare. In Collingwood's system, he often takes the opposition's most dangerous forward, freeing up teammates to play more attacking roles. This selflessness is a hallmark of his game.
The Future
At 28, Maynard is entering the prime of his career. With a contract that runs until the end of 2027, he is set to remain a key figure at Collingwood. But his influence extends beyond the club. As the AFL grapples with balancing tradition and player safety, Maynard represents a bridge between the old-school physicality and the modern, skill-based game.
Whether loved or loathed, Brayden Maynard has earned his place as one of the AFL's most respected and effective players. As one rival coach put it, “If you don't want him on your team, you don't understand footy.”
